An 11-year-old’s baseball card just sold for over $1 million—here’s why

What would you do if you pulled a cardboard card from a pack and, instead of just sticking it in your shoebox, you found out it could be worth more than a house? Welcome to the wild world of collectibles, where, this month, an 11-year-old’s baseball card is making millionaires—and economists—sit up and take notice.

From Playground Swaps to Million-Dollar Auctions

As a kid, I used to collect baseball cards. Not with any real sense of strategy—just like most kids did. You bought a pack, traded a few with your friends, and maybe checked a magazine once in a while to see if one of those cards was worth more than a few bucks. But to us, cards weren’t investments. They were simply a fun way to spend recess.

But what if we’d thought differently? What if, lying hidden in one of those foil-wrapped packs, there was a card that would eventually auction for over a million dollars?

That far-fetched scenario just played out in real life with the Paul Skenes MLB Debut Patch card—a totally unique collectible that’s sent the sports memorabilia scene into overdrive. The hype got so intense that the Pittsburgh Pirates dangled 30 years of home plate season tickets with a boatload of perks for whoever found the card. Even Paul Skenes’s girlfriend, Olympic gymnast Livvy Dunne, pitched in, offering the finder a seat in her private suite.

Scarcity Makes the Market Go ‘Round

Top-level collectors have guessed this card could go for $1 million at auction. But why? What’s so special about a little rectangle of ink, paper, and a swatch of fabric that it’s now more valuable than the average home in Pittsburgh?

Here’s how most markets work: if people suddenly can’t get enough coffee, cafes simply brew more. If a film’s a surprise hit, theaters add showings. Even with collectibles, supply usually rises to match demand—Topps reprints baseball cards of popular players, Nike restocks sell-out sneakers. This elasticity is what usually keeps prices from going completely bananas.

But this time, with the Paul Skenes card, the rulebook goes out the window. There’s only one such card. Not one per shop. Not one per printing. Just one. No matter how many collectors are foaming at the mouth, the number of cards remains exactly the same.

Economists have a term for this: perfectly inelastic supply—a supply curve so vertical it’s basically a wall. With perfectly inelastic supply, price is the only thing that can change. So if a million new fans want this card overnight, the price just keeps shooting higher, since there’s no way to make another one.

Selling the Dream: How Auctions Fuel the Hype

Usually, when prices climb, businesses crank out more stock and the rising cost also dampens demand. But when supply just can’t budge, there’s really only one way left to sort out who gets the goods: auction it off and let bidders battle it out.

That’s exactly what’s set to happen here. The 11-year-old who unwrapped the Skenes card could have taken the Pirates’ 30-year game ticket offer, but let’s face it—how many LA kids are desperate for three decades of Pirates games? Instead, they’re opting for the auction route, and the card’s final price will be decided the classic way: whoever’s willing to pay the most, walks off with the prize.

Contrast this with the typical baseball card market. Most players have dozens of cards—rarity, condition, and edition play a huge role in their value. A banged-up 1952 Mickey Mantle fetches far less than a pristine one. In almost every case, there’s wiggle room in supply: companies can print more, and private collectors might decide to release a card from their safe. Even precious commodities—like gold and diamonds—can increase in supply if prices are tempting enough to convince miners to dig deeper, despite the higher costs.

But the Skenes card? There’s no secret stash, no reprint, no spare supply. That’s why a single piece of paper and fabric, probably produced for pennies, is headed for a seven-figure payday. Oh, and the 11-year-old winner has said they’ll donate some of the proceeds to support wildfire relief in Los Angeles. Not bad for a recess hobby!

Taste, Scarcity, and a Million-Dollar Lesson

At the end of the day, what sets this card apart isn’t the ink, paper, or even Skenes himself—it’s sheer scarcity. There’s something mesmerizing about watching economic principles play out live. As a former casual collector, I can’t help but wonder how many of my own childhood cards ended up in the trash when maybe—just maybe—they could’ve been worth something.

Economists like to say, 1de gustibus non est disputandum.2 Or, for those who skipped Latin: 1there’s no accounting for taste.2 We don’t judge what people value; we just observe what they’re willing to pay for it.

Most of us wouldn’t dream of dropping a million dollars on a baseball card. But someone will. And in the rarest of markets—where supply won’t budge an inch—only one thing truly matters: the size of the highest bidder’s offer.

Thanks for reading Monday Morning Economist! If you liked this dive into the economics behind the headlines, feel free to share it with a friend—or consider becoming a paid subscriber to help this newsletter keep growing.